I’ve moved to WordPress: http://bobtisdale.wordpress.com/

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Update of Recent Differences Between GISS and NCDC SST Anomaly Data And A Look At The Multiple NCDC SST Datasets


In a post at Climate Audit “Bob Tisdale on SST”, Steve McIntyre noted that NOAA has stated, regarding their ERSST data, that “V3b is now the official version. V2 will no longer be updated. It will still be available in our subdirtectory /Datasets/noaa.ersst/V2/'”

There is no date on the notice from NOAA, and it has been my understanding for a few months that ERSST.v2 would no longer be updated.


The ERSST.v2 data available through the KNMI Climate Explorer is current through April 2009. Go figure.

Thanks again to Steve McIntyre.


Reynolds, Smith, and Liu gave the reasons for removing the satellite data from ERSST.v3 data as, “In the ERSST version 3 on this web page WE HAVE REMOVED SATELLITE DATA from ERSST and the merged product. The addition of satellite data caused problems for many of our users. Although, the satellite data were corrected with respect to the in situ data as described in reprint, there was a residual cold bias that remained as shown in Figure 4 there. The bias was strongest in the middle and high latitude Southern Hemisphere where in situ data are sparse. THE RESIDAL BIAS LED TO A MODEST DECREASE IN THE GLOBAL WARMING TREND AND MODIFIED GLOBAL ANNUAL TEMPERATURE RANKINGS.” [Emphasis added.]

The link for that quote is here:

So, how much did the removal of the satellite data change the appearance of the Southern Ocean data? Figure 1 is a comparison of the ERSST.v3 and ERSST.v3b versions of the Southern Ocean SST anomalies from January 1970 to April 2008, smoothed with a 12-month running-average filter. It clearly shows the change to the annual temperature rankings of the Southern Ocean.

Figure 1

Figure 2 is a long-term comparison of the ERSST.v3 and ERSST.v3b SST Anomaly data for the Southern Ocean, smoothed with a 37-month filter. With the smoothing, the ERSST.v3 version has been cooling since the 1980s, and in the ERSST.v3b version, the cooling was delayed for more than a decade. There also appear to have been some other adjustments made to the earlier data that would not have been a part of the satellite data fix.
Figure 2


The ERSST.v3b SST anomaly data is available through the NCDC’s ERSST.v3 webpage:
Link to the available datasets:
I used this dataset for this post:

I used the obsolete ERSST.v3 I had on file for the comparison graphs.


Unknown said...

Bob, KNMI is getting its data from here (V2 shows an update on May 11, 2009)


Bob Tisdale said...

Steve: Thanks for the link.

If I had to guess, I'd say there are a number of researchers using the ERSST.v2 data, and they complained when NCDC failed to update it. Hence the delay in the update to the 11th, where the ERSST.v3b data gets updated on the 3rd of each month.


Tips are now being accepted.

Comment Policy, SST Posts, and Notes

Comments that are political in nature or that have nothing to do with the post will be deleted.
The Smith and Reynolds SST Posts DOES NOT LIST ALL SST POSTS. I stopped using ERSST.v2 data for SST when NOAA deleted it from NOMADS early in 2009.

Please use the search feature in the upper left-hand corner of the page for posts on specific subjects.
NOTE: I’ve discovered that some of the links to older posts provide blank pages. While it’s possible to access that post by scrolling through the history, that’s time consuming. There’s a quick fix for the problem, so if you run into an absent post, please advise me. Thanks.
If you use the graphs, please cite or link to the address of the blog post or this website.